(1) 1889-92 William C. Graff (17) 1933-35 Daniel F. Hinkle (2) 1892-93 Lewis Shelhorn (18) 1935-40 Harry P. Boughey (3) 1893-96 A. Percival Hodgson (19) 1940-41 Ross E. Purinton (4) 1896-97 John W. Stilwell (20) 1941-46 Samuel J. Maconaghy (5) 1897-99 George L. Shaffer, Jr. (21) 1946-48 Wallace H. Harris (6) 1899-1901 John Ellery (22) 1948-53 Desmond Heyliger (7) 1901-03 William H. Bisbing (23) 1953-61 C. Paul Felton (8) 1903-06 William L. Gray (24) 1961-67 William A. MacLachlan (9) 1906-08 William Warren Sweet (25) 1967-74 John W. Gilbert (10) 1908-10 William S. Dawson (26) 1974-85 Lane A. Weller (11) 1910-13 Edward H. Hoffman (27) 1985-99 David J. Frame, Ph.D. (12) 1913-17 George G.Dilworth (28) 1999-2000 Sandra F. DuFresne (13) 1917-19 Lloyd P. Stevens (29) 2000-02 Byron D. Leisure (14) 1919-21 William F. Ewing (30) 2002-2006 Daniel R. Ellis- Killian, Ph.D. (15) 1921-30 Harry R. Johnson (31) 2006 – 2008 Felicia Kumar (16) 1930-1933 Richard B. Wells (32) 2008-2015 Cynthia E. Skripak (33) 2015-Present Lorelei Krall Toombs
In addition, the Conference appointed Rev. H. David Loughery as Assistant Minister 1969-1972 Other Assistant Ministers retained by the local church included Rev. Barry A. Boyle, Rev. Henry Renn, Rev. Walter H. Canon, and Rev Howard Pinter.